---
title: Is the surgeon the most important choice in cataract and lens replacement surgery?
description: "![review cataract surgery 11](https://bluefinvision.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/review-cataract-surgery-11-530x1024.jpg) ## Patient Experience \"I was very nervous about the Bilateral lens replacement surgery with Zeiss trifocal lenses. My mother had cataract surgery in 2012 at the inexpert hands of the NHS and as a consequence experienced…"
url: "https://bluefinvision.com/knowledge-base/topics/patient-experience/is-the-surgeon-the-most-important-choice-in-cataract-and-lens-replacement-surgery/"
updated: "2026-11-16"
category: Patient Experience
tags:
  - Cataract Surgery Reviews
  - Lens Replacement Surgery Reviews
---

# Is the surgeon the most important choice in cataract and lens replacement surgery?

![review cataract surgery 11](https://bluefinvision.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/review-cataract-surgery-11-530x1024.jpg)

## Patient Experience

"I was very nervous about the Bilateral lens replacement surgery with Zeiss trifocal lenses. My mother had cataract surgery in 2012 at the inexpert hands of the NHS and as a consequence experienced a catastrophic outcome in her right eye leaving her with complete loss of sight in one eye.

When I learned I was developing cataracts I knew I had to find the very best eye surgeon in the UK to do the procedure. After 2 years of research and several blind alleys I settled on Mr Hove.

As soon as I sat in front of him and we discussed the procedure and his recommendations I knew I could trust him to deliver the very best outcome possible for me. I agreed to have the procedure the same day as my initial consultation and now, 8 weeks later, I couldn't be more pleased. No cataracts and 20/20 vision in both eyes for the rest of my life.

The procedure is not without risk as my family know only too well, but Mr Hove explained all the possible risks and most importantly how they would be addressed in the unlikely event they should occur. Planning for failure is even more important than planning for success in such a procedure.

My partner is now commencing his journey for his bilateral lens replacement surgery with Zeiss trifocal lenses after having supported me through mine."

*Verified patient review. Source: Doctify, 13 November 2026.*

## What This Patient Is Describing

This patient spent two years choosing a surgeon before choosing anything else. We think that is the right order. The lens, the technology and the price all follow from a judgement about one pair of eyes, made by one person, who then carries out the operation and answers for the result.

Cataract surgery is one of the safest operations performed in the UK, in the NHS and in private practice. In the national audit, the main complication during surgery, posterior capsule rupture, occurs in 0.70% of operations.¹ This means a tear in the thin capsule that supports the lens.

The serious sight loss this patient's mother experienced is rare. The words used to describe it are the patient's own, about care we were not part of and cannot judge.

Rare is not the same as equal. The risk of a complication varies with the eye, the patient and the surgery.² When the capsule does rupture, national data link it to a much higher risk of retinal detachment surgery and of infection inside the eye.³ Retinal detachment means that the light-sensitive layer at the back of the eye separates from its supporting tissue. That is why the consultation matters as much as the operation.

## Why Our Consultations Are Paid

At Blue Fin Vision®, the cataract and lens replacement consultation is a paid appointment, covering the consultation and the diagnostic tests. The fee pays for the consultant's time and judgement, and for the measurements that judgement rests on, whatever the conclusion. It means the advice does not depend on surgery going ahead.

We are paid to consult, not to sell. In practice that means:

- The consultation is booked for 45 minutes and is conducted throughout by the consultant. It is not delegated.
- Every suitable option is presented, including options this practice does not offer.

A credible assessment must be capable of saying no: to surgery, to a premium lens, or to operating now. The decision to accept that advice, or to seek another opinion, belongs to the patient.⁴

The trade-offs are explained before surgery, not after. Lenses that give a range of focus bring more haloes and glare than monofocal lenses, which provide one main focusing distance.⁵ Haloes are rings around lights, while glare is difficulty seeing clearly around bright light sources.

Most dissatisfaction after such lenses has an identifiable and treatable cause,⁶ but it is better prevented by the right choice of lens at consultation.

Mr Hove has the same trifocal lenses in his own eyes. Trifocal lenses provide three focusing ranges: distance, intermediate and near.

The surgeon who advises is the surgeon who operates. Where an enhancement, meaning an additional procedure to refine the visual result, is needed after surgery with us, the same surgeon performs it. Any potential enhancement or further treatment policy will be explained clearly during consultation.

This patient had lens replacement surgery. The week before, they had a video consultation with Mr Hove. The consultation in person and the operation then took place on the same day, which patients who travel a long way often choose.

It is a choice and never an expectation. Every patient must have the information and the time they need to decide,⁷ including the risks that would matter to them,⁸ and a consultation can always end without surgery.

Lens replacement is elective refractive surgery, meaning planned surgery chosen to correct the eye's focusing prescription. The professional standards recommend at least a week between the surgeon's recommendation and the operation, with surgery not taking place on the day the recommendation is made.⁹

The same standards allow that first consultation to be by video, provided it takes place at least a week before surgery.⁹ That is why, for lens replacement patients who travel, we arrange a video consultation with the surgeon a week before surgery.

Cataract surgery is different. It treats disease, so the refractive cooling-off period does not apply, although every patient still has the time they need to decide.

## Who This Applies To, and Who It Does Not

This applies to adults considering [cataract surgery](https://bluefinvision.com/cataract-surgery/) or [lens replacement](https://bluefinvision.com/lens-replacement-surgery/) who are comparing where to have it, and to anyone made anxious by a relative's poor outcome.

It does not apply as a promise. No surgeon can promise an outcome. This patient writes of 20/20 vision for the rest of their life. The term 20/20 describes measured visual sharpness, not a guarantee of lifelong vision or eye health.

A cataract cannot return once the natural lens has been removed. The capsule behind the new lens can become cloudy months or years later, which is treated with a YAG laser. YAG stands for yttrium aluminium garnet, the crystal used in the laser. The treatment creates an opening in the cloudy capsule to allow light through.

Capsule clouding is the most common long-term problem after cataract surgery, recorded in about one in five eyes by three years in national data.¹⁰

In pooled published studies with at least two years of follow-up, retinal detachment was about twice as frequent after lens replacement as after cataract surgery.¹¹ ¹² Those are pooled estimates, not Blue Fin Vision® results or any one person's risk.

Individual risk, which is higher in short-sighted eyes, is discussed at consultation. Other eye conditions can still develop with age.

Not every eye is suitable for a trifocal lens. Suitability is decided at consultation.

## Surgeon Interpretation, Mr Mfazo Hove

"Patients often arrive having researched lenses and lasers. I would rather they researched surgeons. The first surgeon is the most consequential decision a patient makes, because every later decision is made with that person and the outcome belongs to them.

We charge for the consultation for a simple reason: I want to be free to advise against surgery. If I ever have to refer a patient back to the small print, I may win the argument, but the war is lost."

## Clinical Takeaway

Choose the surgeon first, and look at the team, the facilities and the arrangements that stand behind them. Then expect that surgeon to consult, not sell.

**References**

1. Royal College of Ophthalmologists National Ophthalmology Database Audit. Ninth annual report of the National Cataract Audit. London: Royal College of Ophthalmologists; 2026. Available from: https://nodaudit.org.uk
2. Sim PY, Donachie PHJ, Day AC, Buchan JC. The Royal College of Ophthalmologists' National Ophthalmology Database study of cataract surgery: Report 17, a risk factor model for posterior capsule rupture. Eye (Lond). 2024;38(18):3495-3503.
3. Day AC, Donachie PHJ, Sparrow JM, Johnston RL. The Royal College of Ophthalmologists' National Ophthalmology Database study of cataract surgery: report 1, visual outcomes and complications. Eye (Lond). 2015;29(4):552-560.
4. General Medical Council. Good medical practice. London: General Medical Council; 2024. Paragraph 18.
5. de Silva SR, Evans JR, Kirthi V, Ziaei M, Leyland M. Multifocal versus monofocal intraocular lenses after cataract extraction. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016;12(12):CD003169.
6. de Vries NE, Webers CAB, Touwslager WRH, Bauer NJC, de Brabander J, Berendschot TT, Nuijts RMMA. Dissatisfaction after implantation of multifocal intraocular lenses. J Cataract Refract Surg. 2011;37(5):859-865.
7. General Medical Council. Decision making and consent. London: General Medical Council; 2020.
8. Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11.
9. Royal College of Ophthalmologists. Professional standards for refractive surgery. London: Royal College of Ophthalmologists; 2024.
10. Donachie PHJ, Barnes BL, Olaitan M, Sparrow JM, Buchan JC. The Royal College of Ophthalmologists' National Ophthalmology Database study of cataract surgery: Report 9, risk factors for posterior capsule opacification. Eye (Lond). 2023;37(8):1633-1639.
11. Passaro ML, Kilic D, Virgili G, Romano V, Lucenteforte E, Dick B, Taneri S. Retinal detachment incidence in refractive lens exchange versus cataract surgery: uncommon versus rare: systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Ophthalmol. 2025;109(7):756-764.
12. Correction: Retinal detachment incidence in refractive lens exchange versus cataract surgery: uncommon versus rare: systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Ophthalmol. 2026;110(3):e1.
